Assessing Your Competitive Moat

Everyone claims a moat. Few actually have one. Here's a practical framework for honest assessment.

The Moat Types

1. Network Effects

Value increases as more users join.

Assessment Questions:

Does adding a user make the product more valuable for existing users?

Can competitors achieve the same network with enough marketing?

How strong is lock-in once users are in the network?

Scoring:

Strong: Value compounds exponentially with users

Medium: Some network benefit but not essential

Weak: Network is nice-to-have, not must-have

2. Switching Costs

Changing to a competitor is painful.

Assessment Questions:

How much data would customers lose?

How much retraining would be required?

What integrations would break?

Scoring:

Strong: Multi-month migration with significant risk

Medium: Weeks of work, manageable risk

Weak: Days to switch, minimal friction

3. Economies of Scale

You can do things cheaper at size.

Assessment Questions:

Do unit economics improve dramatically with scale?

Are there infrastructure advantages only possible at scale?

Can startups achieve similar economics with VC money?

Scoring:

Strong: 10x+ cost advantages at scale

Medium: 2-3x cost advantages

Weak: Marginal scale benefits

4. Brand

Customers choose you because of who you are.

Assessment Questions:

Would customers pay more for your product than an identical alternative?

Do customers actively seek you out vs. compare alternatives?

Does your brand defend against feature competition?

Scoring:

Strong: Brand commands premium, drives demand

Medium: Brand is recognized but not decisive

Weak: Brand is unknown or commoditized

5. Counter-Positioning

Incumbents can't copy you without hurting themselves.

Assessment Questions:

What would competitors sacrifice to match you?

Is that sacrifice material to their business?

Is your position structurally different or just tactically?

Scoring:

Strong: Copying you would be existentially threatening

Medium: Copying is possible but painful

Weak: They could copy if they wanted

Your Moat Score

Add up your scores across the five dimensions:

5+ Strong: Defensible position

3-4 Strong: Good but not invincible

1-2 Strong: Vulnerable

0 Strong: No moat—compete on execution

---

Assess your competitive position. Get intelligence →